Roll On Deodorant Vs Stick: Which Is Better?

Choosing the right deodorant might sound simple, but when you end up at a store and look at the wide range of products there, confusions begin. Whether it is a physical store or an online shopping website, there are different types of deodorants being sold. However, the most common ones are roll on deodorants and stick deodorants. But the question is, roll on deodorant vs stick — which is better and what works the best? To help you comprehend better, here is an article that gives a better insight on both these products.

As a consumer, you certainly want to know which works the best between roll on and stick deodorant? Well, multiple factors might influence the choice of a deodorant formula. Though both the products save the same purpose, their features, ingredients, and usage make a difference.

roll on vs stick deodorant

Roll On Deodorant vs Stick

Both stick and roll-on deodorants offer a smooth application on the skin. A gel-based roll-on leaves a wet or watery feeling while a stick does not. For excess sweaters, roll-on deodorants might not last long, as it gets washed off with perspiration. Stick deodorants stay longer but can leave flaky substances after the sweat.

1. Primary Roles

Both roll-on and stick deodorants are designed to serve the same purpose – reduce the underarm odor. The ingredients used in them can be different, but their roles are similar.

2. The Differentiating Features

Many people perplex themselves with these two products. The reason is simple – they come in same size and package. However, both are entirely different. Here is a quick difference:

  • Roll-on Deodorant – Packed in liquid or gel form. The bottle has a rolling ball through which the liquid flows.
  • Stick Deodorant – Packed in soft solid form and is non-sticky. The bottle has a twister at the bottom through which the stick can be made to slide up and down.

3. Fragrance & Ingredients Used

Since the topic is about roll on deodorant vs. stick, the key points lie in what they contain.

Ingredients:

Though the forms they come in are different, most ingredients used in both roll-on and stick deodorants are the same. They have antimicrobial agents like triclosan, parabens, and alcohol to neutralize the underarm odor.

Often, alcohol is one of the most common chemicals used in deodorants. It helps absorb the product quickly and simultaneously, inhibits the growth of bacteria that cause bad odor. Since roll-ons are wet in nature, alcohol is prevalent in them than sticks. But this can cause irritation in people with sensitive skin. Hence, it is important to read the ingredients beforehand.

Fragrance:

Besides antimicrobials helping to control bad odor, most brands selling sticks and roll-ons use two things to add fragrance – either artificial scents or natural essential oils. The chemical-based fragrances can irritate the skin or cause allergies whereas the natural oils are harmless unless you are allergic to them.

Feel:

Since a roll-on deodorant is either a liquid or a gel, it leaves a wet, watery sensation after it is applied. However, the case of a stick deodorant is different. The non-sticky, soft solid form leaves a smooth application. There is no wet feeling after it is applied. The silica used in stick deodorants help absorb the excess grease.

roll on vs stick deodorants

Advantages & Disadvantages Of Roll-On Deodorants

No.

Advantages

Disadvantages

1

Has a smooth rotating ball or applicator that dispenses an even flow of the liquid. Using roll-ons that contain antiperspirants might be a risk. The aluminum might cause breast cancer.

2

Gives a cool, wet sensation after it is applied. Does not last long. You might have the need to reapply.

3

Prevents bacterial growth. Takes a long time to absorb. Can stain the clothes.

4

Leaves a mild fragrance behind. Masks the bad odor. The fragrances and chemicals can cause rashes, burning, irritation, and allergies.

Advantages & Disadvantages Of Stick Deodorants

No.

Advantages

Disadvantages

1

Holds the bad odor for longer periods. Once you start to sweat, the applied stick deodorant starts to crumble, flake and then produces small balls.

2

Soft solid, which makes the wastage less. Stains the clothes easily.

3

The application is smooth. Leaves no wet feeling. The twister makes it easier to control. Can cause irritation and other skin allergies.

4

Easier to find in shops when compared to roll-ons. Their thickness can easily block the skin pores when compared to the liquid form.

Conclusion: Roll On vs Stick Deodorant

  • Excess sweater? Dislike the wet, watery sensation from roll-on? – Go for stick deodorants
  • Hate the thick flaky residues from stick? – Go for roll-on deodorants

Both roll on and stick deodorants function the same way. They help in fighting bacteria and prevent bad odor. Both the products are smooth to apply.

It depends on an individual’s personal preferences because some might not like the wet or watery sensation in roll-ons while others hate the flakes that the stick deodorants form after sweat. So, one has to try both the deodorants to see which feels comfortable and what works the best for his or her skin.

Show CommentsClose Comments

Leave a comment